I really loved talking about jacket copy with you guys on
Tuesday. And I am going to do more posts like it soon! But not today. Because that post made me think about all the reasons people pick up or don't pick up books. My Scientific Analysis (TM) goes something like this:
1) Author recognition
2) Cover art
2) Title
3) Jacket copy
Author recognition...well, that's the whole platform thing agents talk about a lot. So I'm going to let them do it because they do it better than me. Cover art? Maybe another day, but there's also lots of blogs devoted to cover art.
Next up is titles.
I've been reading a TON of agent blogs every day for over a year now. A few posts have mentioned titles. Mostly, the advice boils down to "a great one isn't necessary--just a bonus. But God kills a kitten every time you invent a really, really bad one. So, proceed with CAUTION."
If great titles are a bonus, WE ALL WANT ONE, don't we? YESSS. But what makes a title great? Who knows? All I can do is talk about ones that hooked me, and try to figure out why. Without the cover art, without author recognition, without the jacket copy (though in cases, I did proceed to the flap if the title made me sufficiently curious).
And with that, below is my list. I am keeping it YA in this post. Some of these books I've read, and some I haven't, but I tried to recreate the thought process that occurred when I first discovered them. Here goes:
LIST O' TITLES THAT MAKE ME DROOL: Living Dead Girl - How can you be a LIVING dead girl? Very curious.
Looking for Alaska - Why does anyone need to look for Alaska? It’s on a map. Oh…Alaska is a person. How unusual. Ok, where did she go?
Tithe - Ooh. Sinister. What’s being tithed? Or…WHO is being tithed?
The Adoration of Jenna Fox - The ADORATION of? Strong word. Who is adoring Jenna Fox? Why?
Madapple - What is madapple? It sounds sinister and wild.
The Forest of Hands and Teeth - A whole FOREST of random body parts? WHY?! So creepy. So AWESOME.
Tender Morsels - Such evocative words. What, or who, are the tender morsels? And who is eating them?
The Demon’s Lexicon - What IS a demon’s lexicon? TELL ME.
The Catastrophic History of You And Me - WHAT HAPPENS that’s so catastrophic?
A Love Story: Starring My Dead Best Friend - How can someone’s dead best friend star in a love story? Wouldn’t that make it a SAD story? Very curious.
I Am Number Four - A person is being numbered? Weird and creepy. In like Flynn.
Like Mandarin - WHAT is like Mandarin? Mandarin is a—oh, wait. It’s a person. With a very unusual name. She sounds interesting and unusual. And who, or what, is like her? Very curious.
Incarceron - I don’t know what this means, but incarceration = imprisoned, and that’s kind of cool. But it’s been made into a noun. Interesting.
The Fat Girl - So blunt. Sharp. Who would call someone “the fat girl?” And what happens to her?
Andromeda Klein - I want to read about someone named thus so badly. SO BADLY.
The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau Banks - The DISreputable history? Why so disreputable, Frankie Landau Banks? I love that character name so much.
The Brilliant Fall of Gianna Z - Juxtaposition? Play on words? How can a fall be brilliant? I have many questions!!
The Dust of 100 Dogs - ONE HUNDRED? That’s a lot of dogs. And what is dog dust? I want to know.
How to Say Goodbye in Robot - How DO you say goodbye in robot? What the HECK does that even mean?
The Ear, the Eye, and the Arm - Random body parts. I AM SO THERE. But why THESE parts? MUST KNOW.
Total Oblivion, More or Less - Oh god, this voice. Love this voice already. And what's in total oblivion?! TELL ME MORE IN THAT VOICE.
The Sweet Far Thing - Sounds…sexy. What IS this thing that is sweet and far?
Spanking Shakespeare - Shakespeare is dead. Why would someone want to spank Shakesp—oh. OH.
The Hunger Games - Is this an eating disorder book? Are people playing games to avoid eating? Sounds dark and sinister. Love.
The Perks of Being a Wallflower - What ARE the perks of being a wallflower?
Going Bovine - How can someone go cow-like?
The Secret Year - Why so secret?
Aaaaand...DONE! For now! Here is what I learned from this experiment: the one thing pretty much all of these titles have in common? They made me ask questions. Sometimes a LOT of questions. Sometimes weird questions. But in each case, questions that made me want to pick up the book to get those questions answered. Food for thought.
What do YOU think of the titles I listed? Did you have the same reactions? Similar reactions? COMPLETELY OPPOSITE reactions that made you go "WTF is Michelle smoking today?!" Other examples of titles that make YOU drool? Let's hear it.
PS: I know that authors don't control the title of their book once it's sold, but we DO control the title before it's submitted to agents. And if it can give us a boost, let's figure out that magic and bottle it!